The LLC 3-way: A Perfect Tax Structure πŸ˜‰



Ask your accountant, and they'll tell you "It depends."

Ask your attorney, and you'll get a novel of an email and a $1,000 invoice.

But all you really want is someone to tell you how to set up your business to get started without stepping on a landmine. πŸ’₯

If you feel this, today is your day. We're going into the structure I advise in a lot of entity structuring and planning calls I have (if you want one customized, just reply to this email to get set-up).

This design includes the best parts of all three passthrough entity structures and can add 10-15% ANNUAL post-tax efficiency πŸ’° to an investment when executed.

Let's go πŸš€

Who This Works Best For

The basis of tax structuring is identifying a few driving factors:

  • πŸ”€ Income streams - how is this venture really going to make money
  • πŸ‘¨β€πŸ‘¨β€πŸ‘¦β€πŸ‘¦ Capitalization - how is this venture going to be financed? Cash flow? Equity from investors? Debt?
  • 🏭 Balance Sheet - what will the balance sheet look like? Is this CAPEX heavy?
  • 🫑 Exit - what does the exit look like?

Many times, a S-Corp will be sufficient for a lot of side hustle start-ups because they only have one income stream, will cash flow any purchase needs (no debt), and any exit will be a purchase of client lists or similar.

But for those businesses that will require debt, outside investors, a heavy balance sheet, and have multiple income streams, the above structure captures a lot of the tax leakage.

Examples for who this works for: real estate syndicators (raise investor money and debt to buy a building), CAPEX-heavy SMBs that will use investor debt and equity, SBA loan-financed purchases.

Let's get into it.

AssetCo - Partnership

We prefer partnerships to hold appreciating assets subject to debt and with outside investors who will be passive. Think PropCos (property level entities) with limited partners (LPs).

Three reasons we like partnerships over S-Corps:

  1. Flexibility in distributions - 1031s via TICs (tenancy in common), re-capitalizations and step-up in basis both remain possible with a partnership. πŸ§˜β€β™‚οΈ
  2. Increase in basis for losses and distributions - a partnership increases your basis by the debt that is either guaranteed by you or which is qualified non-recourse (real estate specific). That means higher tax efficiency for losses generated by the AssetCo and non-taxable distributions. ⬆️
  3. Flexibility in income and loss allocations - unlike S-Corps, partnerships allow for more creativity in investor returns. Specifically, a promote or carried interest that can be earned by the sponsor / GP / syndicator is eligible for capital gain treatment. This layer of return is not eligible for S-Corps. πŸ”„

ManagementCo - S-Corp

Here, we isolate unique income streams. The GP or operator is due separate fees for their work in running the business. This is outside of the promote or carried interest mentioned above. This income represents more like management fee income but can also include asset management fees, development fees, and acquisition fees.

We want to run those fees, when they are large and recurring enough, through a S-Corp for two ✌️ reasons:

  1. Qualified Business Income Deductions - many times if these fees are paid directly to the operator or to another partnership, the beneficiaries can lose out on serious QBI deductions because there is no way to increase QBI "base" (e.g. W2 salary) to increase the otherwise allowable deduction. A S-Corp allows for this extra layer of tax efficiency.
  2. Self-employment Tax - even after considering a reasonable salary to the owner, a S-Corp can save on self employment tax on the fees otherwise paid to the operator directly. That is 15.3% up to $176k and 3.8% on anything over $250k. This can easily add up to $10k-$12k in savings a year. πŸ€‘

At the risk of repeating myself, we RARELY want to put real property and appreciating assets subject to debt inside of a S-Corp. πŸ™…β€β™‚οΈ If you insist on DIYing a set up before getting professional help, your #1 rule is Don't F*** It Up. And putting real estate and assets subject to debt inside a S-Corp is a good way to violate that rule.

Co-invest - Disregarded Entity

If you as the operator / GP / syndicator are contributing your own capital to the property / business that is subject to debt, you want to hold this in your personal name or through a disregarded entity.

You do not want to hold your interests in the partnership through your S-Corp unless otherwise given the okay. πŸ”

The primary driver of this is to protect the debt basis from the partnership. Owning your equity investment / co-investment through the S-Corp / MgtCo undoes that debt basis. Meaning, if losses are financed through debt (think bonus depreciation), you want to be able to use those without running into basis limitations that S-Corps have.

The Bottom Line

This isn't for everyone - you need a certain level of complexity in your venture to need this. But it can save you hundreds in thousands in tax over the lifetime of your business - especially if you're doing it more than once.

Your takeaway today should be to think about the primary drivers of tax structuring and apply them to your business set-up:

  • Income streams - how is this venture really going to make money
  • Capitalization - how is this venture going to be financed? Cash flow? Equity from investors? Debt?
  • Balance Sheet - what will the balance sheet look like? Is this CAPEX heavy?
  • Exit - what does the exit look like?

Want to watch a breakdown instead? Check it out on YouTube:

video preview​

🫑


πŸ”₯ Hottest Finance Posts This Week πŸ”₯

twitter profile avatar
Roger Ledbetter
Twitter Logo
@rledbetterCPA
3:6 PM β€’ Aug 25, 2025
1
Retweets
67
Likes
​
twitter profile avatar
Ramp Capital
Twitter Logo
@RampCapitalLLC
8:40 AM β€’ Aug 29, 2025
5
Retweets
188
Likes
​
twitter profile avatar
Boring_Business
Twitter Logo
@BoringBiz_
4:48 PM β€’ Aug 25, 2025
404
Retweets
4932
Likes
​
twitter profile avatar
JUNK BOND ANALYST
Twitter Logo
@junkbondanalyst
6:45 AM β€’ Aug 27, 2025
3
Retweets
44
Likes
​

Enjoying The Plug?

Help it grow πŸ‘‰

πŸ”Œ Forward this on to a friend, colleague, or client

πŸ”Œ Check out more purely tax alpha on my podcast - Today in Tax Court - and follow me on X @rledbettercpa

πŸ”Œ Reply to this email to set-up a paid consultation re: tax, accounting, or firm management

πŸ”Œ Reply to the poll below, or email me and let me know what you thought πŸ‘‡

​

Want to read previous issues? Click here.​

The Plug [Newsletter]

I've been a CPA for nearly 20 years - serving private small business and real estate the entire time. I take the lessons learned in serving and now running a small business and share them here. For business owners, investors, and advisors looking to lower their cost of capital, subscribe for delivery straight to your inbox πŸ‘‡ Also on YouTube at PlugAccountingandTax!

Read more from The Plug [Newsletter]

If you can get past the absurdity of the name πŸ™„, the new Trump Accounts are worth looking into for those in the gifting stage of life. While this newsletter is geared towards small business and real estate, reducing tax burn to the ultimate taxpayer is the end game - and since this new gifting 🎁 account has a business component, it's fair game. So let's talk Trump Accounts 🀦 We'll cover a few pieces of it: What they are How most people will use them How business owners can use them What are...

I'm currently reading The Outsiders: 8 Unconventional CEOs πŸ“– - a book that was on Warren Buffett's must read list in 2012. One of the points it makes early on is about the need for CEOs to be good investors πŸ“ˆ at heart. They are stewards of capital and so constantly analyze inputs to make the best decision for shareholders and the business. The same holds for small business, with one tiny wrinkle: a drastically smaller finance team. 🀏 Until your business gets to $10 million in revenue, it's...

CPAs and tax preparers (shout out to all my EA friends) get a bad wrap for adding zero value to their clients. So when we have a chance, we have to be ready to lay the pipe and bring it. πŸ’ͺ One of the best ways I've done this for my real estate (and small business) clients is through a good scrub of their operating agreement (OA) - with practical suggestions and changes. If you are the client, this is an incredible way you can bring value to your LPs as well as save yourself some tax - by...