If investors know one thing it's how much cash they contributed 💸 and what they've received in return. 🫴

Loss allocated to them over the years? Nah.

Capital gain treatment vs. ordinary income? CPA jargon.

Debt basis coded as qualified nonrecourse for at-risk? Nerd stuff.

But those are pretty important distinctions that drive whether the money they receive as a distribution is actually taxable - and if taxable, at what rates.

GPs think in terms of (1) returning capital, and (2) paying off pref(erred returns).

Tax-smart advisors work to explain and integrate 🤝 the three points of view (investor, GP, tax) into a practical explanation - which is what we'll do today.

The Basics

Let's start with the alpha. Here's a quick table to help explain common disconnects:

Distributions can take many different forms - from operations (income), preferred returns, refinance proceeds, returns of capital, and sales proceeds.

The Drivers of Tax Impacts

Tax pros are looking at three things to determine if the investor will owe tax on that distribution:

1. Underlying partnership activity - does the partnership show net taxable income or loss?
2. Partners individual basis - what is the partners capital account (contributions + history to date income - history to date loss - history to date distributions) + their allocated debt?
3. The Operating Agreement - what are the terms used to describe the preferred returns?

A few examples to illustrate:

• Example 1 - In year 1, if the partnership performs a cost segregation study, there will be losses allocated to partners. If there are also distributions made, then those distributions will be tax-free return of capital. And the losses allocated will also reduce the partners capital account (and therefore basis in the partnership).

• Example 2 - After the property is stabilized, if a refinance is performed (assume guaranties removed) and proceeds are distributed to partners, those distributions aren't automatically taxable. But if the partnership shows net operating income (since it's stabilized), the partners may have income allocated to them - though much less than the refinance distribution.

• Example 3 - In early years, if a higher class of equity is receiving preferred returns "regardless of income of the partnership," (language usually in the Operating Agreement) then those distributions would be taxed as guaranteed payments regardless of if the partnership had taxable income or loss.

Year of Sale - "My Equity Was Wiped Out, Why Is There Gain?!"

This is one of the most common questions ❓❓❓ we get when preparing returns during sale years - especially for properties that underperformed.

The question usually comes with a very accurate record of (1) how much cash he contributed, and (2) how much cash he received back. If the investor received back as distributions less than their contribution, they expect a loss not a gain.

Welcome to the wonderful world of pass-through taxation. 🤗

The usual culprit is losses incurred over the life of the partnership and allocated to them in previous year. Especially if a cost segregation study was performed.

These losses lower their capital account and basis in the partnership - many times well below the original contribution amount. So when the tax man cometh, the math shakes out to there being income on even a "loss" of a deal.

The silver lining is that many investors can have these "phantom gains" shielded by previously suspended passive losses from this same property. But if they previously used those losses allocated to them, then it is what it is.

The Takeaway

Your LPs will remember two numbers: what they put in and what they got back. They won't remember the cost seg losses that cratered their basis in year one. They won't remember the guaranteed payment language buried in Section 4.3 of the operating agreement. They won't remember that the refinance proceeds hit their account the same year the property flipped to net income.

But they will remember whether you had answers when the K-1 showed gain on a deal they lost money on. The allocator who can walk them through that conversation clearly, before they have to ask, is the one who keeps their trust.

🫡

Meme Cleanser 🧼

Want to read previous issues? Click here.​